Bucky Blog
How Cars Stopped a Seniors' Homes in a Cartierville Convent
An empty convent, 148 units for seniors, no additions and no demolition. Neighbours forced a referendum over traffic that was already there.

Bucky Blog
An empty convent, 148 units for seniors, no additions and no demolition. Neighbours forced a referendum over traffic that was already there.

Add Bucky as a preferred source to see our latest articles more often in Google Search.
Bucky turns an address into sourced zoning, site constraints, and what you can actually build there. No credit card required.
• The former Sœurs de Miséricorde convent at 12435 avenue de la Miséricorde in Cartierville has been empty since March 2020. • Its owner asked the borough to allow a "maison de retraite": 148 units for people 65 and over, inside the existing building. • The work was interior: new windows, an emergency exit, a redesigned cafeteria. The cross, the statue, the cemetery and the park stay. • Neighbours objected over traffic from private-school drop-offs and parking from Hôpital du Sacré-Cœur. • 74 signatures were needed to force a referendum. 192 people signed on October 13, 2026. • The site's current institutional zoning still allows community, educational, religious and health uses.
Montreal just lost 148 homes for seniors.
And it didn't have to.
Nobody fought the building. Nobody fought the seniors. The fight was about cars, and most of them weren't even coming from the project. Let me explain.
There's an old convent in Cartierville, at 12435 avenue de la Miséricorde. It was built in 1929 and expanded in 1967. A tower with a cross on top. A chapel with a statue out front. A small cemetery and a little park beside it.
It's kind of a neat building. (It even has a pool.)
The Sœurs de Miséricorde lived there for about 90 years. In 2018, a developer bought it for $7 million, with a plan to renovate housing for the sisters. That developer went bankrupt. The sisters moved out in March 2020, right as COVID hit, and the building has been empty ever since.
Then the current owner came along with a plan: turn the convent into a residence for seniors. 148 units for people 65 and over.
Look at what the plan didn't include. No new wing. No extra storeys. No demolition.
New windows, an emergency exit and a redesigned cafeteria. The cross stays. The statue stays. The cemetery and the park stay.
Nothing added, nothing knocked down. Just a renovation.
I come from architecture and approvals, and from that side of the table, this is about as gentle as a project gets. The building is already there. The use is quiet. The project's architect, Étienne Taillefer of MDTP, called it "le choix le plus calme": the calmest choice.
Cars. Just not the seniors' cars.
Parents drive kids to two private schools nearby every morning. People who work at or visit Hôpital du Sacré-Cœur, a short walk away, park on the surrounding streets because there isn't enough parking at the hospital.
The streets are already full. So when neighbours saw 148 new units, they saw more cars.
"La goutte est peut-être grosse, mais le verre est plein." (The drop may be big, but the glass is full.) A Cartierville resident at the April 2026 consultation
I get it. Nobody wants to sit in traffic on their own street.
But here's the thing. That traffic comes from the schools and the hospital. Stopping the convent doesn't take a single car out of the morning drop-off.
In Quebec, a change of use like this one can be challenged by the people who live around it. If enough eligible residents in the neighbouring zones sign a register, the change goes to a referendum.
The bar was 74 signatures. On October 13, 2026, 192 people signed.
It wasn't for lack of trying. The developer held its own meeting with residents in August. The borough ran workshops on traffic and parking. The owner's side even asked supporters to stay home on register day: "La meilleure façon de soutenir le projet, c'est de ne pas y aller."
Three days later, La Presse put it plainly: citizens had derailed the project.
This is the part I keep coming back to.
If senior housing is too much traffic, what isn't?
The site's current institutional zoning still allows community, educational, religious and health uses. A school means more drop-offs. A clinic means more people circling for parking. That was the owner's argument all along: of the options on the table, a seniors' residence was the one with the least traffic.
So the likely outcome right now isn't a quieter use. It's no use at all. A building from 1929, empty since 2020, heading into another winter.
That's why at Bucky we look past what the zoning allows and ask what a site is really up against. Here, it was never the building.
So I'll ask you what I asked in the video: what do you think should go here instead?
The convent was never the problem. It was the traffic!
Cartierville | Des citoyens font dérailler un projet de maison de retraite
Published October 16, 2026 · Accessed November 20, 2026
La nouvelle vie tourmentée de l'ancien couvent des Sœurs de la Miséricorde
Published May 1, 2026 · Accessed November 20, 2026
« Ne signez pas ! », dit le propriétaire du couvent des Sœurs de la Miséricorde
Accessed November 20, 2026
Référendum demandé pour la conversion du couvent des Sœurs de la Miséricorde
Published October 14, 2026 · Accessed November 20, 2026
Énoncé de l'intérêt patrimonial: site de la maison-mère des Sœurs de Miséricorde
Published August 28, 2019 · Accessed November 20, 2026